Fraud Blocker
Skip to content Skip to footer

Choosing Between Vinyl vs Laminate Flooring – 5 Things to Consider

Choosing new flooring is like choosing the stage for all your home’s special moments.

And when it’s time to decide, homeowners find themselves deciding between two popular options: vinyl vs laminate.

Why these two? Both offer attractive designs and durability at a price that won’t make your wallet weep. This makes them household favorites. 

However, the similarities can make it tough to pick the perfect one for your home.

This guide will dive deep into what sets these floors apart. Whether you’re renovating a cosy cottage or sprucing up a sleek studio, understanding these factors will help you lay the groundwork for a place you’ll love to live in. 

Understanding the basics — what are vinyl and laminate flooring?

When you’re looking to give your floors a fresh start, it helps to know what you’re stepping into. Vinyl and laminate flooring are both strong in their own right, but different at the core.

What is vinyl flooring?

Vinyl flooring is like the chameleon of floors—it can look like almost anything. Made mostly from a special type of plastic called PVC, it’s strong and flexible. 

You’ll find vinyl in two main types: luxury vinyl tiles (LVT) and luxury vinyl planks (LVP). LVT looks like stone or ceramic tiles, while LVP mimics the look of real wood planks. 

Both types are known for their ability to take on high traffic without complaining too much, making them perfect for busy homes.

What is laminate flooring?

Think of laminate flooring as a sandwich. 

The bottom layer (or backing) keeps everything stable. The next layer is the core, usually made from dense fiberboard, which gives the floor its heft and feel. 

On top of that, there’s a decorative layer that looks like wood or stone, thanks to some very clever printing. The final touch is a protective overlay that shields the floor from scratches and spills. 

Common finishes on laminate flooring can vary from glossy to matte, offering options for different looks.

So, what’s the big difference between vinyl and laminate? 

Vinyl is all about flexibility and moisture resistance, making it a champ in kitchens and bathrooms where spills are part of daily life. 

Laminate, however, stands out with its sturdy feel and realistic appearance, making it ideal for areas where aesthetics is your priority. 

5 factors to consider when choosing between vinyl and laminate flooring

Deciding between vinyl and laminate flooring isn’t just about picking the prettiest option. It’s about what works best for your life. 

Each type has its strengths and weaknesses, so your choice really boils down to your requirements. Are you looking for something that can handle splashes in the kitchen or a stylish but affordable option for your living room? 

By weighing the pros and cons of each, you’ll find a flooring solution that looks great and fits seamlessly into your daily routine.

Factor #1 — durability and longevity

When it comes to flooring, “tough” is the name of the game. 

Both vinyl and laminate are strong contenders, but how do they stack up in the real world of foot traffic, pet claws, and dropped toys?

Because of its PVC composition, vinyl flooring is slightly softer underfoot and can bounce back from minor bumps and drops.  This flexibility also means vinyl hides wear and tear better, making it great for busy homes where life’s little accidents happen. 

Plus, it’s water-resistant, making it ideal for bathrooms or kitchens where spills are a daily thing.

Laminate, on the other hand, boasts a tough top layer that’s great for resisting scratches. It’s a bit harder than vinyl, which makes it feel more like real wood underfoot. 

However, laminate can suffer in high-moisture areas. It’s not naturally water-resistant. 

Under typical conditions, laminate can last just as long as vinyl, especially if you’re careful with water and don’t constantly rearrange your furniture.

If your home is a high-traffic zone with pets and kids running around, vinyl might be the better bet. For a sturdy feel and a wood-like appearance, laminate could be your go-to, especially in drier areas of your home.

Factor #2 — battle of the budgets

When choosing between vinyl and laminate flooring, your budget often has the final say. It’s not just the sticker price you need to consider, but also what you’ll spend in the long run.

Vinyl flooring can vary in cost, depending on the quality and style you choose. Luxury vinyl tiles (LVT) and planks (LVP) might cost more upfront, but their durability and water resistance often justify the initial investment. 

Installation can be straightforward, and many types are designed for easy, do-it-yourself projects, which can save on professional installation fees.

Laminate flooring typically offers a lower initial cost compared to vinyl. It’s also known for easy installation, thanks to click-and-lock design systems that eliminate the need for glue or nails. 

However, if your subfloor needs preparation to smooth out imperfections, this could add to your total cost. And while laminate might seem cheaper upfront, remember that it doesn’t handle water well. If it gets damaged, you might end up replacing it sooner than expected.

The best choice depends on your budget, how long you plan to stay in your home, and the room you are renovating. 

Factor #3 — style and aesthetics

Both vinyl and laminate offer beautiful options that can set the tone for your entire home.

Vinyl flooring is truly versatile, perfect for those who love to change their home’s look now and then. 

From the cosy feel of wood to the cool elegance of stone or even trendy polished concrete, vinyl can match any style. The printing technology is so good, your guests might think it’s the real deal until they touch it

Laminate flooring offers a feast for the eyes as well, especially if you love the classic beauty of wood. Its high-definition photographic layer is a work of art in itself, offering clarity and colour that mimic the real thing beautifully. 

And if you’re looking for variety, newer laminate styles now include stone and tile looks, giving you more ways to spruce up your space.

Factor #4 — comfort and underfoot feel

Vinyl and laminate feel different under your toes, which can be a big deal.

Vinyl flooring is generally softer. It’s more forgiving and bouncy, making it a great choice if you spend a lot of time on your feet – especially in kitchens and bathrooms where bare feet are a thing. 

Plus,  it feels warmer underfoot, which is a bonus in cooler climates. Additionally, vinyl does a decent job of dampening sounds, which can make your home quieter overall.

While not as soft as vinyl, laminate flooring, still provides a comfortable walking experience. It usually feels more like hardwood without the high cost and upkeep. 

However, laminate can be louder when walked on, especially if not installed with the proper underlayment that helps with sound insulation. It might also feel colder underfoot, which could be a factor in colder homes.

So, which wins for comfort? It depends on what you prefer.

Do you crave softness and warmth, or are you okay with a firmer feel? Noise levels in your home are also a factor to consider.

Factor #5 — maintenance and cleaning

When it comes to flooring, low-maintenance options offer big relief. Both vinyl and laminate floors are known for their ease of cleaning, but with a few twists.

Day-to-day, a quick sweep or a gentle mop with mild detergent will keep vinyl flooring looking fresh. It’s also resistant to moisture and stains. This means spills can be wiped up without a fuss, and it won’t harbor mold or mildew. 

For deeper cleans, you can use a vinyl-specific cleaner. However, it’s best to skip the harsh chemicals and scrubby brushes that can damage the surface.

Laminate flooring is also very easy to clean. Similar to vinyl, regular sweeping and occasional damp mopping usually do the trick. 

However, since laminate is not fully waterproof, it’s important to avoid using too much water. Excess moisture can seep into the seams and cause swelling or damage. 

Special laminate cleaners can help protect the decorative surface and keep your floors sparkling clean.

Make the smart choice for your floors

Think about what matters most in your daily life.  

Do you need super-tough floors that can handle spills and splashes? Or are you more interested in a classic wood look and feel?  

Think about the rooms you’re renovating, the foot traffic they’ll see, and how much time you want to spend on maintenance. Weigh these factors carefully, and you’ll find the flooring that looks great and makes life a little easier. 

Remember, the best choice is the one that meets your needs, brings comfort, and makes you happy.

Leave a comment